Bonner Online-Bibliographie zur Comicforschung
Korneliussen, Ina: Tegneseriens narrative virkemidler. Eksemplificeret ved analyse af to værker af Jason.(Speciale), Aalborg Universitet 2009 (106 S.).
|Resource type: Thesis/Dissertation
BibTeX citation key: Korneliussen2009
View all bibliographic details
Keywords: "Lomma full av regn", "Si meg en ting", Jason, Narratologie, Norwegen
Publisher: Aalborg Universitet (Aalborg)
|Attachments||URLs http://projekter.aau.dk/projekter/da/studentthesis/tegneseriens-narrative-virkemidler%28b3245e7a-4d90-4e34-988e-6316292cbfb2%29.ht ...|
The purpose of this master’s thesis is to investigate the narrative means specific to comics. The investigation is based mainly on the theories by Scott McCloud and Thierry Groensteen, and I exemplify with analysis of Pocket full of rain (1995) and Tell me something (2000) by Norwegian comic book artist Jason. Though many identities in theme and plot, these comics present very different uses of the narrative means, and can thus be used to examine the narrative means from different angles.
Based on the definitions of comics proposed by McCloud and Groensteen, I find that there are at least three levels of narrative means specific to comics: the images, the spatial relations (page layout) and the causal relations (which are primarily sequential). Furthermore, I include the verbal as a fourth level in my system of terminology.
The images are the material comics are made of, and I explain their functions as a part of the narrative project and how these functions motivates certain characteristics of the narrative drawing. Furthermore, I examine the use of various styles in comics and how the reader identifies with the cartoon. In my view, the verbal is not a defining trait, but still words play an important role in the narration of many comics. I investigate the relationship between words and pictures using Barthes’ concepts anchorage and relay and McCloud’s word/picture combinations. Page layout is investigated from Groensteen’s idea about the spatio-topical apparatus. I investigate the functions of the panel, the frames, and the balloons and of the page layout as a whole. The sequential relations between the panels are the level where the narrative project is carried out. McCloud explains how the sequences give meaning through the concept of closure and set up categories of transitions based on degrees of closure. Groensteen states that the narrative structures do not have to be linear and discursive, they can be based on translinear relations and “braiding” as well.
Jason’s Pocket full of rain is a bittersweet love story. Drawn in a realistic style with occasional use of a cartoony style, the images thematise their own credibility. Likewise, the use of the verbal adds ambiguousity to the narrative. The page layout as well as the sequences adds to a fragmentary narrative style, which prompts the reader to draw her own conclusions. The story is contained in a “frame narrative” about the victim of a hired killer, and involves various genre tropes, such as zombies and aliens, and is hereby constantly questioning the credibility of the diegesis. The metafictive dimension is generally supported by the ambiguous use of the narrative means.
Tell me something, also a love story, presents a very minimalistic use of the narrative means. The style is very simplistic, the page layout is mainly plain regular, and the verbal is almost entirely left out! The silent comic genre is here combined with elements from silent film, such as slapstick comedy. The story consists of two parallel narrative courses, which are linked on many levels and can be read as one. The plot is based on a melodramatic model which stands opposed to the iconographic style and the impassive faces. To sum up, my analysis shows that the narrative means of the images, the verbal, the page layout and the sequential relations are intersecting and should not be regarded separately. In any analysis of a comic, all four levels of narrative means must be considered. Comics are not just a mixture of word and image, but constitute a unique language of its own.
De første skridt mod forståelse (10)
Tegneseriens narrative virkemidler
Analyse: Lomma full av regn
Analyse: Si meg en ting
English abstract (98)
PHP execution time: 0.01271 s
SQL execution time: 0.23331 s
TPL rendering time: 0.00119 s
Total elapsed time: 0.24721 s
Peak memory usage: 1.4753 MB
Memory at close: 1.4251 MB