Bonner Online-Bibliographie zur Comicforschung
Bateman, John A. und Janina Wildfeuer: "Defining units of analysis for the systematic analysis of comics. A discourse-based approach." In: Studies in Comics 5.2 (2014), S. 373–403.
Added by: joachim (04 Sep 2015 01:33:13 UTC)
|Resource type: Journal Article
BibTeX citation key: Bateman2014
Email resource to friend
View all bibliographic details
Keywords: Analyse, Sprache
Creators: Bateman, Wildfeuer
Collection: Studies in Comics
Views index: 2%
Popularity index: 0.5%
Although regularly contested and rejected, the idea of a ‘grammar of comics’ continues to be applied to the analysis of comics in many disciplines and frameworks. The motivation for this is the evident regularity and systematicity exhibited by the comics medium as a form of expressive communication. Less commonly realized is that nowadays there are powerful descriptive mechanisms developed in approaches to verbal texts and linguistics that do not require the assumption of ‘grammar’ to explain productive structural regularity. This is important for the future study of comics because the notion of ‘grammar’ is in many respects deeply problematic when applied outside of its home area of natural language. In this article we demonstrate how more recent accounts of dynamic discourse provide a more appropriate set of mechanisms for talking about visual media such as comics. These mechanisms allow us to naturally relate panel, page and multiframe compositions as well as their combinations. By critical discussion of examples addressed in the literature, we show how these constructs also entail treatments of panel transitions that move beyond overly tight linking of panels and panel transitions to time and space and offer a methodologically sound way of identifying units of analysis in comics in general.