Bonner Online-Bibliographie zur Comicforschung
El Refaie, Elisabeth: "Visual modality versus authenticity. The example of autobiographical comics." In: Visual Studies 25 (2010), S. 162–174.
Added by: joachim (07 Feb 2011 18:27:09 UTC)
|Resource type: Journal Article
BibTeX citation key: ElRefaie2010
Email resource to friend
View all bibliographic details
Keywords: "Fun Home", "Heart Throbs", "Persepolis", Autobiographie, Bechdel. Alison, Cabanes. Max, Frankreich, Iran, Satrapi. Marjane, Semiotik, USA
Creators: El Refaie
Collection: Visual Studies
Views index: 2%
Popularity index: 0.5%
This article exposes some of the weaknesses of the social semiotic concept of ‘visual modality’ in analysing the perceived truthfulness of images, by contrasting it with the more productive notion of ‘authenticity’. Using three autobiographical comics as examples, I argue that Kress and van Leeuwen’s notion of modality is unable to capture adequately the complex relations that can pertain between images and reality, as it places too much emphasis on picture-immanent stylistic markers and neglects the performed element of truthfulness. In the case of autobiographical comics, ‘producer-oriented’ forms of authenticity seem to play a more important role than stylistic features in determining whether or not visual representations are likely to be seen as truthful.
Added by: joachim